Bath might be toasting a historic treble, but Simon Shaw didn’t hold back when it came to the atmosphere at Twickenham — labelling the showpiece Premiership Final everything from “stop-start” to “uninspired”.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages. Despite Bath edging Leicester Tigers 23-21 to lift their first Premiership trophy in nearly three decades, the former England lock took to LinkedIn (yes, LinkedIn) to unload on a final he says never got out of second gear.
“The atmosphere, early on, was convivial. Anticipatory and joyful, but almost too Cotswold village fete, as opposed to a deep seeded tribal clash of titans!
Shaw’s blistering review didn’t stop there.
“The rugby never came alive. What should have been a final full of grit, pace and heart became a disjointed stop-start affair riddled with refereeing interventions, laboured kicking, and a visible lack of invention from both sides. Neither Bath nor Leicester imposed themselves. Neither seemed able to find rhythm."
Ouch.
Twickenham, often sold as the cathedral of English rugby, didn’t escape criticism either — with Shaw laying into everything from the limp crowd engagement to “boot sale” speaker systems.
“Then there was the fan engagement—or lack thereof. A couple of food stalls. A few clapper boards. A promo tent here or there. It all felt unimaginative, flat. Like someone remembered they needed to “do something for the fans” and threw a few stickers at the problem."
“The anthem? Dan Cole looked more upset at that than he did after his ludicrous sending off moments into his last ever match! If he had his moment again I would wager he accepts a red by taking the guitarist out!"
And in true Shaw fashion, he didn’t just stop at the matchday experience. The media coverage — or lack of it — was also in his crosshairs.
“The Metro newspaper, the UK’s most-read print daily, gave the final one square inch of column space on the day before the match. One. Right next to the table tennis results, presumably."
“Meanwhile, Trent Alexander-Arnold’s potential move to Real Madrid was given a full page and a half. Why? Because he greeted the Spanish press in 'fluent Spanish'. Apparently that now qualifies as back-page headline news."
His message to rugby? Shape up — or risk slipping further into irrelevance.
“Rugby doesn’t just need better matches. It needs better storytelling. Greater relevance. A media presence. It needs to stop hoping that tradition and loyalty will carry it forward, and start creating events worthy of attention, on and off the field."
“The stage is grand. The script? It needs rewriting.”
EDITORS PICKS:
2/10: 5 Big-Name Underperformers from the Premiership Final
Bath finally broke their 29-year title drought with a nervy 23-21 win over Leicester Tigers, wrapping up a historic 2024/25 treble. But while the blue, black, and white were partying, some big names had a day to forget...
Honourable Mention: Dan Cole (Leicester Tigers)
?
Farewell in a fogA brief cameo turned sour as the veteran prop bowed out of professional rugby with a c
ontroversial yellow card for a late hit on Finn Russell. Rugby Pass called it
"a tragic way to finish his career."Rating: 2/10#1. Joe Cokanasiga (Bath)
? Big Joe's big slip-up
He found himself in good positions but couldn’t make them count. Handling errors crept in, undermining his usual wrecking-ball threat.
"Unusually mistake-filled… unable to hold the ball," noted RUCK.
Rating: 5/10 (Planet Rugby), 6/10 (RUCK)
#2. Adam Radwan (Leicester Tigers)
? Nowhere to run
Radwan had flashes of pace, but spent much of the match marooned in heavy traffic. His defensive work didn’t help either.
"Bath dominated in the air and Radwan also missed quite a few tackles," Planet Rugby observed.
Rating: 5/10
#3. Handré Pollard (Leicester Tigers)
? The pass that broke the Tigers
Started brightly, directing play with authority, but his second-half unravelled. A stray pass to Russell led to a decisive Bath try, and he missed a crucial kick at goal.
"Blew white hot and ice cold," summed up Planet Rugby.
Rating: 5/10 (Planet Rugby & Rugby Pass)
#4. Freddie Steward (Leicester Tigers)
? Grounded under pressure
The safest hands in England were tested—and cracked. Bath’s tactical kicking drew him out of position, and a few spilled catches followed.
"Not his imperious best under the high ball," said Rugby Pass.
Rating: 4/10
#5. Tommy Reffell (Leicester Tigers)
? Breakdown? Break-gone.
Normally a menace at the ruck, Reffell struggled to assert himself and racked up penalties instead. Bath kept him largely out of the contest.
"Found himself on the wrong side of Dickson’s whistle… not Leicester’s afternoon at the breakdown."
Quiz! Can you name every club that has played in the Premiership?
London Welsh were the last new team to play in the Gallagher Premiership back in 2011 – can you name the others?
You have five minutes to name every club to have played in the Gallagher Premiership, all 28 of them, since the division was established back in 1987.
It’s more difficult than it sounds.
Good luck, and let us know how you do