Sir Ian McGeechan’s All-Time Top 5 Rugby Player Picks Spark Debate

, the 77-year-old has named his all-time XV — featuring , , , and one each from .

A true rugby brain and coaching legend, “Geech” has shaped the game with his tactics and mentorship. No wonder he’s seen as one of the sport’s greatest minds.

Writing for The Telegraph

Oh, and his top five players ever? Let’s just say there’s a big name from both England and Wales in there

Revered as rugby's unstoppable force, Lomu was a New Zealand legend whose mere presence struck fear into opponents.

His unmatched blend of size, speed, and skill revolutionised wing play, leaving an indelible mark on the sport.

McGeechan wrote: “Illness and injury ultimately slowed him down.

"But his performances at the 1995 World Cup, just as the game was turning professional, will never be forgotten.

"The game needed a superstar, and it got one in Lomu. He was brilliant for rugby.”

Renowned for his fierce leadership and unyielding determination, Johnson captained England to Rugby World Cup glory in 2003.

A towering figure both on and off the field, his uncompromising style made him a symbol of rugby excellence.

He wrote: "I think he defined an era, both for forward play and for the performances of the teams he represented."

Widely regarded as one of rugby's greatest fly-halves, Carter's precise kicking, silky running, and tactical brilliance set him apart.

A two-time Rugby World Cup winner with New Zealand, his influence transcended eras, inspiring generations of players.

McGeechan wrote that Carter “really was the complete 10."

He added: "His defence was immaculate, he could break himself, he could bring others in to play, his kicking from hand and from tee was incredibly accurate.

"He also changed the way the game was played with his kicking from his own 22m and his kicking to compete. The greatest of the modern era in my opinion."

A dynamic force in New Zealand's storied rugby legacy, Brooke's versatility and flair elevated him to legendary status.

1

Renowned for his powerful runs, deft handling, and pinpoint accuracy, he became a symbol of the All Blacks' relentless pursuit of excellence.

He wrote: "His ability to bring others into the game, his ability to stay connected in the game himself, popping up repeatedly through different phases; all exemplary.

"And he dropped goals of course. A true original."

A Welsh icon and arguably the greatest scrum-half in rugby history, Edwards redefined his position with his exceptional vision, speed, and game-changing abilities.

A key figure in Wales' golden era of the 1970s, his name remains synonymous with rugby brilliance.

McGeechan wrote: "My favourite scrum-half of all time happens to be my favourite player of all time. Gareth Edwards was and always will be the master. The Greatest."