— but feels like a backward-looking rather than progressive choice.
The Rugby Football Union may be publicly backing Steve Borthwick, but after a disappointing Six Nations campaign, the pressure is only intensifying—and contingency plans are clearly being drawn up.
⭐ Save us to your Google Favourites for nonstop RUCK content! According to RugbyPass, an
11-man shortlist of potential successors is already doing the rounds.
From proven international winners to rising Premiership coaches and high-profile overseas names, the list underlines both the scale of England’s expectations and the urgency of their current predicament.
Scott Robertson
A hugely successful coach with the Crusaders and strong attacking identity.
Verdict: Serious contender — but only if he’s actually available. Contract complications and recent All Blacks tensions make this uncertain.
Ronan O'Gara
Built a formidable side at La Rochelle and has clear Test ambitions.
Verdict: Very strong contender — ticks most boxes, but Ireland may be his preferred next step.
Andy Farrell
Elite-level operator with deep England ties and current Ireland success.
Verdict: Ideal but unlikely — timing (World Cup cycle) makes a move improbable.
Rob Baxter
Proven Premiership winner and deeply respected builder of teams.
Verdict: Outside-but-plausible — RFU like him, but he’s not the flashy pick.
Phil Dowson
Highly rated domestically and seen as a future England coach.
Verdict: Dark horse — might come too soon, but he’s clearly on the pathway.
Shaun Edwards
One of the best defence coaches in the world with a winning pedigree.
Verdict: Romantic but tricky — prising him away from France is the main obstacle.
Johann van Graan
Has transformed Bath and built a winning culture.
Verdict: Unlikely — may prefer to wait for a future Springboks opportunity.
Jamie Joseph
Experienced international coach with Japan and Super Rugby pedigree.
Verdict: Long shot — credible, but not a front-line RFU target.
Michael Cheika
Former World Cup finalist with a strong personality.
Verdict: Wildcard — has pedigree, but current commitments and timing count against him.
John Mitchell
Already inside the RFU setup and highly experienced.
Verdict: Left-field but practical — low disruption option, though not a statement appointment.
Jake White
World Cup-winning coach with vast experience.
Verdict: Experience pick
POLL:
EDITORS PICKS:
RUGBY QUIZ: