The Welsh Rugby Union have today published their promised formal consultation document on the future of elite rugby in Wales. They labelled it as their ‘proposed optimal system’, which covered loads of major talking points, including two clubs, four elite teams set up for excellence to win at the highest level. Typically, for Welsh Rugby journalists, this time of year is about getting supporters ready for the upcoming United Rugby Championship (URC) season or the 2025 Women’s Rugby World Cup with insight and previews of what is to be expected; however, the summer of 2025 hasn’t been plain sailing, certainly not for Welsh Rugby.
The formal consultation, which begins early next month, will attempt to address the key challenges that Welsh Rugby have been facing and the impact that today’s announcement will have on both the professional and national teams.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages. This is the WRU’s optimal solution, a reduction in the number of regions from four to two, as “it’s clear that the Welsh elite rugby system is no longer achieving its aims”. To summarise, the need for change has never been more substantial, as the four male professional teams - Cardiff, Ospreys, Dragons, and Scarlets- are not funded at a level where they can compete.
The male playing talent is spread out over too many clubs, so it was highlighted that key players for the national side do not play together enough at the right competitive level.
The proposed optimal system contains five interdependent elements which will work together to enhance performance in the top echelon of the game. One of those elements is the two clubs- each made up of one professional men’s side and one women’s side (locations and names to be determined).
The model of two professional clubs will be funded for “excellence”, and the WRU’s ambition is to deliver a systemic transformational change for the future success of Welsh Rugby. The performance expectations are to be raised as follows;
To put it simply, the game in Wales is at a crossroads, and whatever decision is made to improve the game in Wales will create a “long-term, sustainable, and defensible competitive advantage”.
Speaking about the consultation, WRU CEO Abi Tierney said: “We are clear that the current rugby model in Wales is no longer delivering what our game needs.
“That’s why we’re inviting views on the opportunities for change we’ve put forward — so we can bring the One Wales Strategy to life.
“This consultation is about listening. No decisions have been made, and it’s crucial that we work together. Every voice matters, including, critically, our professional clubs, and everyone must have a seat at the table to help shape the future of rugby in Wales.”
The deadline for the consultation is expected to be announced by the Board at the end of October. By then, all four professional male teams would have played five URC matches before some regional players will be heading into the Welsh camp ahead of a crucial 2025 Quilter Autumn Nations Series.
Spearhead of the WRU’s executive team, Director of Rugby and Elite Performance, Dave Reddin added: "This is a genuine consultation process and while we have our own ideas based on the research we have done, we know the best solutions come from listening.
“The approach we have designed is respectful, thorough, and inclusive, and we encourage people to challenge our ideas and help us create something that we can all get behind.”
Reddin also stated in a media press conference, which lasted nearly an entire rugby match, that small nations like Wales need to collaborate. That’s where they proposed a new rugby campus, which has been labelled as a “generational investment” with the main aim of quickly improving collaboration.
The proposed facility will have six pitches with four indoor 4G pitches, with several shared facilities which will bring together up to 400 players and staff. Along with the male and female teams and staff, the four professional sides will also be based on the campus.
“This is about designing for elite performance, it’s about concentration of talent in an environment that makes that talent outperform its inherent capacity, that’s what we are looking to do”, stated Reddin.
“The national campus would be a purposeful, collaborative space, a uniquely Welsh environment that other top-tier nations would find difficult to replicate, creating a sustainable, collaborative space that provides the competitive advantage needed to increase our performance levels in all aspects of the game from playing to coaching.”
The Transformational systemic pathway will also see investment into the newly formed Super Rygbi Cymru league, which only began last season. Whilst there will also be a substantial amount of focus on the pathway, where they will expand player development centres and help coaches for future success.
WRU chair, Richard Collier-Keywood, said, “I am pleased to see that this consultation includes listening to people from all aspects of the game in Wales. Every player and fan story starts somewhere, and we have encouraged our teams to get a full range of views from grassroots through pathways, up to elite level.
“The important thing for us as a Board is that, when we are presented with an updated recommendation in October, we know we will have listened and considered all the feedback and options before making a decision.
“We have a once-in-a-generation opportunity to get this right and create an exciting future for our game, and this is a responsibility we are taking extremely seriously.”